Holes In Thoughts

Saturday, December 06, 2008

Quiet Politics

Ben Smith has been on the ball about Obama's promises about a Muslim-Western summit promised in Obama's first 100 days of office. This promise's importance was eventually elevated onto the campaign website. The NYT says Cairo is a possibility, though a donor has said that Obama pointed to Jakarta privately among donors:

"Obama told the 20 or so of us at breakfast that 'his first trip as President would be to Indonesia - the world's most populous Muslim country,'" Leary recalled.

"He then said when he got off [Air Force One], he would say 'xxxxxxxx' - which we, of course, didn't understand," Leary emailed. "He said that it was Indonesian (which he speaks) for, 'I am back, dudes.'"

I've been particularly interested in Obama's interaction with the Muslim world as President, for two reasons:

Firstly, I don't think there's any doubt that he can do a world of good on the hearts-and-minds front in the War on Terror. Simply being who he is - the American son of a relapsed African Muslim - he has more credibility than Another Old White Guy. There are 1.5 billion Muslims living in the world today (compared to 2.1B Christians and 1B non-religious), and the fact is that a tiny, tiny fraction of them can be called 'militant.' However, any respite fringe lunatic Muslims will receive outside their group will come from other Muslims; It doesn't seem realistic to me that al-Qaeda operatives would ask a Christian for a place to stay. So America - through Obama - must appeal to those billions of Muslims to quietly report, try, and convict the disturbed members of their own population.

We've made some progress. I think this described a lot of international Muslims' attitudes in 2005:

"A few weeks ago an American I met at a friends house asked a much repeated query, 'Why do you the Muslims hate the Americans?' To which I answered in the same way as all the preceding instances in which this question was posed to me: 'We don’t hate the Americans, we might disagree with a certain US policy and dislike recent American actions in the Muslim world but we surely don’t hate the American people.'
The American who interrogated me was clearly not convinced with my answer and secretly I wasn't either. The truth is that at present the Muslims hate America and now, they hate not only its policymakers but most of the American people since they have proven recently without a shadow of doubt that they agree with their elite by voting back into office. [...]"

The second thing that both saddens and interests me is that he had to keep these promises relatively quiet during the campaign, lest the emails that railed about his religion become even more fervent in their conviction that he was going to somehow turn the U.S. into Iran, or that his parents had the foresight in 1961 to conclude their half-black almost-bastard son was going to be president and fake birth documentation (both are actually believed by some people, who are very stupid).

This is the hearts-and-minds front that isn't talked about a lot. In addition to the work Obama has to do abroad to convince that America doesn't hate Muslims, he has to get loud parts of America to stop hating Muslims. The last part of the article above says:

"What were you thinking when you threw the Qur'an in the toilet or when you used religion as a means of torture? I fail to see the efficacy of such actions in the so-called war on terror. These methods only point to a deep sickness in your society to which it will take decades for us and the rest of the world to understand its cause and to measure its destructive results. No, the question which someday will have to be answered is why, why do you the Americans hate us the Muslims so much?"

International diplomacy will be slowed or stopped as long as being called a Muslim is a slur in American politics. This is yet another reason for the separation of Church & State: The instant a nation's percieves itself to be for or against any particular religion, you have a Holy War. Holy Wars never, ever, ever, ever work out well for anybody. It's the third classic blunder.

This will not be as hard as it looks. We don't need to have everybody in the streets singing Kumbayah. No amount of work will dispel stereotype - after all there are lots of associations good and bad about Mormons, Jews, and Catholics. (Where would we be without Rabbi/Priest/Minister/Nun jokes?) But most Muslims are just normal people who do weird religious things that aren't much weirder than what other, 'mainstream' religions do: Magic Underpants, insanely long sideburns and beards, quasi-cannibalism, etc.

This will be Obama's toughest job, and frankly I'm not sure how it can best be done.

Labels: America, Catholics, diplomacy, idiots, movies, Obama, politics, religion

posted by Steve @ 11:45 AM 0 comments

About Me

Name: Steve
Home: Tucson, Arizona, United States
About Me: I like to think about things, and I occasionally like to write what I think.
See my complete profile